Next Pair

Updated 2026-04-23

Picked for: Help me choose between the Nike Pegasus v42 and the Brooks Ghost v17.

Best overall

brooks-ghost-17

Lighter, more responsive DNA LOFT v3 foam with better expert reception and equal durability to the Pegasus at the same price.

Alternative

nike-pegasus-42

Firmer, structured daily trainer that excels for gym use and easy miles if you prefer a one-shoe solution.

See how this conversation went →
user: Help me choose between the Nike Pegasus v42 and the Brooks Ghost v17.
assistant: Both are solid daily trainers at the same price point, but they're built for different things — and the Ghost v17 is the more versatile pick here. **Nike Pegasus v42** is a heavier, firmer shoe (292g, ReactX foam feels "lifeless" per FORDY RUNS). It's a do-it-all workhorse — good for easy miles and gym use — but reviewers note it feels outclassed by lighter competitors at the same price. EDDBUD rates it 8.3/12 and finds it "anchored next to peppier" alternatives; FORDY RUNS agrees the ReactX is "lifeless and heavy." It's a safe choice if you love the Pegasus line, but it's not exciting. **Brooks Ghost v17** is lighter (289g), rides on DNA LOFT v3 (a softer, more responsive nitrogen-infused EVA), and has a more balanced cushioning profile. Same 10.0mm drop as the Pegasus, same price ($150), but better durability (400–500 mi vs. the Pegasus's implied lifespan) and expert reception is well-regarded across the board. It's the more versatile shoe for daily training, easy runs, and long runs. **Pick the Ghost v17** unless you specifically want the Pegasus's firmer, more structured ride or you're already locked into the Pegasus ecosystem. The Ghost feels fresher and rides better for the money. Are you rotating between shoes, or looking to replace your current trainer entirely?

Make your own next pair →